How to handle conflicting reviewer advice?

Explain the conflict clearly in your cover letter and state which path you chose and why, citing relevant literature to support your decision.

Revision Notes Template

Thesis Revision Notes Template | Before-and-After Change Log and Response Wording

Use this template to write thesis revision notes with page and line references, before-and-after changes, response wording, and explanations for partially accepted comments.

Start reduction View blind review strategy

AI Search Brief

Direct answer for this topic

Use this template to write thesis revision notes with page and line references, before-and-after changes, response wording, and explanations for partially accepted comments.

Standard layout for the before-and-after comparison table
Page, line, change, and response wording in one note
Polite explanations for accepted or partially accepted comments
Attitude (polite thanks), Accuracy (precise location of edits), and Adherence (solving the specific issues raised).

Topic graph

Related workflows and reference pages

Open format refinement Check university thesis rules Read the GB/T 7714 guide Generate defense slides Prepare defense Q&A Read the defense preparation guide

What this page helps you do first

Standard layout for the before-and-after comparison table
Page, line, change, and response wording in one note
Polite explanations for accepted or partially accepted comments

The triple-A of revision notes

Attitude (polite thanks), Accuracy (precise location of edits), and Adherence (solving the specific issues raised).

Frequently asked questions

How to handle conflicting reviewer advice?: Explain the conflict clearly in your cover letter and state which path you chose and why, citing relevant literature to support your decision.

Visit reduction page Return to help center